Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Martin Savage
Like lurgee said, not all solo album are shit. Thom York is a good exception to that. And unlike Cornell, Tankian is a trained opera singer with a wide range, so I'll wait to hear before judging. The only reason I listen to System of a Down is his voice, not the guitarist's one, even if he's the mind behind the band.
|
Well, don't take me too far out of context. I'm skeptical of solo albums, but I definitely don't go in with the expectation that I will hear the same as I would from the full band. I try to keep my enthusiasm in proper balance with my skepticism. But there's plenty of evidence that Ninhead is right -- solo albums are a bad idea.
With Yorke, for instance, I knew that Kid A & Amnesiac was really his style, so his solo album, to me, was not mind-blowing. but I still enjoyed it. With Cornell, I think his solo work was clearly different from Soundgarden and it worked for what it was -- not Soundgarden. Plus, Cornell had a notoriously bad live singing voice, so I was surprised at the range he had on the solo CD.
Anyway. There are still COUNTLESS solo albums that are just embarrassing vanity projects. (Guns n Roses fans have been waiting a decade for Axl's!) And yet, if you're enough of a fan of the singer, you can look past the horror to at least get something out of it -- even if it's just a discussion on CHUD's forum!