I am also on the "all right but nothing special" side of Garden State. I always freaked other people out by saying Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is better than Requiem for a Dream.
Some time ago, Van Helsing was on TV. I was online, and a friendly acquaintance of mine from college instant-messaged me to inform me of this. I of course friendly declined the offer, saying teh internets would probably entertain me better. It was probably around then that I had to slip in some disparaging comment on the film's quality.
"It's not that bad", she said.
Me: "Yes it is."
Her: "LOL that friar is so funny!"
Mind. Fucking. Blown.
Some time later (I don't think Van Helsing was even over yet), the conversation had turned to Event Horizon - an example of a film she found truly horrid. Now, Event Horizon isn't my idea of a good movie by a long shot, but I just can't bring to hate it as much as I do Van Helsing.
Now what was it that was so horrible about Event Horizon? Shallow characters? Bad acting? Uninspired directing? Nope. Movie science. Black holes don't work that way. Riiiiight.
Fast forward to a few days later; I had put my MSN status on "Go see Children of Men. Not Eragon. Not Saw 3. Children of Men." The same person IM's me.
Her: "LOL Too late!"
Me: "Oh, that's great, you've gone to see Children of Men!"
Her: "No LOL Eragon!"
Me: "Oh. Okay."
Her: "And the next one I'm gonna go see is John Tucker Must Die with a friend and a biiig bag of popcorn! Maybe after that I'll see your movie."
I'd like to remind you that at no point did I pressure anyone into seeing it, she's the one who commented on my MSN status message. Also, I've been remarkably polite in not saying "yeah, all ur moobies are teh suXx0r". But at this point I say, fuck it, let's say something offensive and really rile her up.
Me: "Well, I guess you can't really go and see a quality movie if you bring a girl."
Her: "Yeah, that's probably right."
At this point I start to question not only her taste in movies, but her sanity. Another fifteen minutes pass, and out of the blue she messages me again.
Her: "What's Children of Men about, anyway?"
I give her a short summary.
Her: "Sorry, but that sounds kinda retarded."
I then point out to her that it's no less retarded than dragon riders or schools for wizards or whatever.
Her: "Oooh I love Harry Potter! I am like a total HP expert!"
Some casual Harry Potter discussion follows. Then, a brilliant idea comes to mind.
Me: "Hey, did you know Children of Men was directed by the same guy who did Azkaban?"
Her: "ZOMG how can u liek Azkaban? That was my fave book but they changed sooooo much!"
Pretty much gave up then and there.