GI JOE TEASES BIG, RIDICULOUS FUN

Well, goddamn if it doesn’t look like Stephen Sommers might have made his first really fun movie since Deep Rising. There has been barely a shred of material from his upcoming G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra that caught my eye, but the Superbowl teaser (which Coming Soon has now as an exclusive) looks just ridiculous enough to enjoy.

I’ll still be shocked to find satisfaction by way of script and character (things Deep Rising actually had) but that shot of Snake Eyes leaping onto and from a flipping car definitely implies spectacle. The disintegrating Eiffel Tower, which could have come straight from the old cartoon, is proof enough that this is a movie for 12-year old boys, which is fine. (And fully expected.) As long as it’s a really entertaining movie for 12-year olds, we’ll have a good time.

Besides,  I can always enjoy a little Eccleston. And I’ll admit, I’m looking forward to seeing Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s Cobra Commander.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

DVD REVIEW: EAGLE EYE (2-DISC SPECIAL EDITION)


Spoilers.

BUY IT AT AMAZON: CLICK HERE
STUDIO: Dreamworks Video
MSRP: $22.99
RATED: PG-13
RUNNING TIME: 118 minutes
SPECIAL FEATURES:
Deleted scenes
Road Trip: On Location with the Cast & Crew
• Alternate Ending
Asymmetrical Warfare: The Making of Eagle Eye
Is My Cell Phone Spying on Me?
Shall We Play a Game?
• Gag reel
Photo Gallery




The Pitch

It’s Enemy of the State meets I, Robot except Will Smith looks like Shia LaBeouf.

The Humans

Shia LaBeouf, Michelle Monaghan, Billy bob Thornton, Rosario Dawson, Michael Chiklis, Ethan Embry, Anthony Mackie.

The Nutshell

Slacker Jerry Shaw (LaBeouf) is scraping by in a marginal life, working at a copy center and playing poker just to try to eke out rent money.  His identical twin brother, Ethan, who was the complete opposite of Jerry, smart, motivated, and beloved by his father, has just died in a car crash.  This sets off a string of highly unusual occurrences in Jerry’s life, including finding a roomful of terrorist weaponry and fake passports in his apartment and a call from a woman on the phone telling him he’s been “activated.”  He’s picked up by the FBI for terrorism charges and is aided by the woman on the phone in escaping.  This woman is hooked into everything electronic and shepherds Jerry and his impromptu traveling companion, Rachel Holloman (Monaghan), who’s also been “activated” through an FBI dragnet toward an unknown mission to Washington, D.C.


“Yes, Mr. Spielberg?  It’s Shia.  Yeah, this one is wrapping up.  What else you got for me?  E.T. remake?  Kooky.  Can we do the flying bikes bit with Harleys and leather jackets instead?  OK, I’m in…”

The Lowdown

The concept for Eagle Eye is hardly a new one, but timely as we’ve truly arrived to a point in time where all of our technology is so interconnected as to be ridiculous.  However two key elements would otherwise make this entire movie an exercise in futility and the hoops that have to be jumped through, considering other alternatives, make the film border on the ludicrous.  Shia LaBeouf, who apparently is Steven Spielberg’s newest adopted child, doesn’t get to play to his strengths and the entire film’s lapses in logic ultimately sink it. 

If you read Devin’s review all the way through, then you already know the secret of the mastermind behind all of the shenanigans: it’s the government’s most sophisticated computer brain, ARIA, able to hook into everything electronic, analyze planets of data and keep the US of A safe.  It’s basically a Skynet that hasn’t decided to play Global Thermonuclear War yet.  It can arrange virtually any scenario, draw upon any data source and formulate hopelessly complex scenarios in order to accomplish its goals.  It decides that a few serious changes have to be made and rationalizes this by the words of the Founding Fathers of all things.  The problem is that it’s under safeguards that prevent it from carrying out these plans, which is where Jerry Shaw comes in. 


“Michelle Monaghan, you’ve been activated.  You will proceed home and disrobe in front of your webcam, slowly.  Then you will – “

“Give it up, Oliver…”

In order to make its plans work, ARIA needs Jerry, and orchestrates a Rube Goldberg series of events in order to get him.  Of course Jerry’s not the type of guy that’s easy to root for.  In fact, he’s a loser by choice, having it set in his mind that he’s the parasitic twin that should have been absorbed by his genius twin brother Ethan in the womb.  His fellow fly on the web is single mom Rachel, who is involved because ARIA has threatened her son, who is on a train trip to Washington to play at the Kennedy Center.  On the heels of Jerry and Rachel, who are forced to commit virtually every crime short of murder in order to fulfill ARIA’s demands, are FBI Agent Thomas Morgan (Thornton) and Air Force operative Zoe Perez (Dawson). 


“So yeah, the cutting herself with knives thing and the wanting to be a funeral director thing and the kissing her brother on the lips at the Oscars thing and the writing Jonny Lee Miller’s name in her own blood on her black leather pants at her first wedding thing and the lesbian thing and the wanting to wear vials of each other’s blood around our necks thing wasn’t what ultimately did it in for us.  None of those things.”

“Then what thing?”

“It was the wanting to adopt the whole freakin’ planet thing…”


The two main issues with the plot of the film are that without Jerry’s unique relationship with his brother, the entire thing wouldn’t be possible, and second, that if ARIA is capable of doing everything it can, then it would have been far easier to just take control of a couple of drones with missiles (which it does in one sequence) or a cruise missile in order to accomplish its objectives.  But for the sake of plot, it has to perform like a trained seal in order to make things happen.  And if it’s able to do things like overload a power line and execute a pinpoint drop on some poor bastard, then it shouldn’t have any problem seeing its mission through by less complicated means.  Even taking into account the irreversible need to get Jerry, it still had the missile option rather than the labyrinthine plot it has to undertake.


“Shane?  This is Mackey.  Some chick just called me and said she knows about Crowley.  No I don’t know how.  Did you have an iPhone with you or something…?” 

I like D.J. Caruso and LaBeouf, but a lot of the choices that Caruso makes in this film and how he chooses to present LaBeouf, without playing to his proven abilities, do them both disservice.  I do hope to see them both work again, just not in a sequel.  Monaghan doesn’t get to display much of the likable qualities that she’s capable of as her character is more exposition and love interest (and bomb delivery) than anything else.  Billy Bob though does get the bulk of the juicy character action as his Morgan is a card rife with one liners.  If you can check your brain at the door, like shit getting blowed up real good and conspiracy theories, this might be a decent rental if you’ve seen everything else on the rack or just have to have your LaBeouf fix.


“…and don’t worry about Mikaela, Sam, I’ll take real good care of her…”

The Package
 
The film does look good and the sound is fine, with optional English 5.1 Surround or French or Spanish, with matching subtitles.  This is a two disc set and on Disc 1 are three deleted scenes totaling about 3.5 minutes and an on location featurette, Road Trip, which runs about three minutes.  Disc 2 has more features, including an alternate ending that was the right decision in not using.  Asymmetrical Warfare: The Making of Eagle Eye is a standard but nonetheless pretty good behind-the-scenes that runs about 25 minutes.  Eagle Eye on Location: Washington, D.C. is another location featurette that runs about six minutes.  Is My Cell Phone Spying on Me? is a nine-minute big brother / technology cautionary featurette.  Shall We Play a Game? is a surprising piece where Caruso interviews his mentor and director of WarGames, John Badham and runs about nine minutes.  A gag reel and trailers round out the offerings.


CHUD site “upgrade” complete.  Downloading all Chewer information…

6.0 out of 10

Message Board






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

Slow-Motion Quick-Draw #54 – Taken, Film Critics, and Jedi Mullets.


 

 

Taken is the movie, just released in the U.S., in which the great actor Liam Neeson takes the Steven Seagal role of an ex-spy who moves to Los Angeles to be closer to his teenaged daughter, only to tear onto the path of vengeance and death-bringing when she is kidnapped on a summer trip to Europe.

 

The first thing you will want to know, if you are a person like me who is willing to watch such a film, is that it’s a PG-13.  I don’t know about you, but just about the last thing I want from a revenge picture is the knowledge that I am free to bring my favorite 13-year-old friend or relative along, that there is no scene too brutal or offensive that it could not run on USA or some other basic cable outlet at 4pm on a weekday afternoon.

 

That said, one thing I came to understand while watching Taken is that you really can’t argue with an audience.  The critic and the aspiring filmmaker will (and must) watch this movie with different eyes, but on an audience of laymen it seems that the movie absolutely works. 

 

To the right side of me, there was applause after every act of brutality.  To the left, there was talking at the screen.  And after the credits finished running, there was this conversation between two ushers:

 

 

Usher 1:  “This movie is hot!”


Usher 2:  “You saw it?”

 

Usher 1:  “I want to see it again!”

 

Usher 2:  “Me too!”

 

 

The film critic (which I am not) will look at Taken and point to the incoherent gunfight sequences, the questionable performances from just about every character not played by Liam Neeson, the inconsistent orientation of the action and its arbitrary engine of suspense (96 hours!), the fact that it keeps running for ten minutes longer than it has to, and the strange feeling of xenophobia elicited throughout, considering the international pedigree of the production.

 

The aspiring filmmaker (which I am) will take all of those things into account, but will also need to consider why an audience might be so [pun intended] taken with the movie.  I have a friend who tells me, “Jonny, you think too much – no real person cares about all that film major stuff.”  Honestly, he’s halfway right: there is a certain elemental appeal, particularly to a movie in this genre, in watching a convincingly badass character take two hours to whale on bad people.  But I would argue that by ignoring all of those aspects that the critics will object to about a movie, the ultimate result is most likely a forgettable movie.  The movies that “real people” will remember and add to their home collections and watch again in ten years, like Dirty Harry and Die Hard and more recently The Dark Knight, deliver the elemental thrills WHILE also being able to answer the logistical questions that a critic or a film major would ask.

 

But again, you can’t argue with an audience.  So why does Taken play?  Liam Neeson has a lot to do with it.  Strange to see such an acclaimed actor in a movie like this one, but a guy’s gotta work!  Guess he’s just killing time (and many, many bad guys) until Spielberg calls him again.  Even when he’s dressed up in a Jedi mullet, Liam Neeson is the kind of actor who takes every role seriously, in the best sense – he makes sure that he is convincing as the character he is playing, and he has the ability to make the audience care about what he cares about.  That’s why, even though his daughter in the movie establishes herself pretty quickly as pretty annoying, you absolutely want him to save her.  And to kill every last person who threatens her.  The script is smart enough to give Neeson that improbable scene, where he talks his daughter through her initial abduction (“This is the hard part; they’re going to take you now”) and the trailer people were smart enough to put that scene in the trailer, because my man sells it all.

 

Lesson learned.  Luckily, it won’t take nearly as much time to explain the wide [pun intended] appeal of Paul Blart, Mall Cop.  To paraphrase the great Chris Farley, “Fat man fall down.”  Boom!  Thirty million!

 

 

 

 

 

P.S.  In the department of things that are funny only to me:

 

Early on in Taken, Liam Neeson’s old company buddies are introduced.  They seem interesting enough to be featured in more scenes, so naturally they all disappear after the first half hour.  Anyway, one is played by the solid character actor Leland Orser (you’d recognize his face) and the other two characters are named Bernie and Casey. 

Bernie… and Casey… 

Bernie… Casey.


 

Bernie Casey.


 

You’d definitely recognize his face.  (Spies Like Us, Sharky’s Machine, Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure, Revenge Of The Nerds, I’m Gonna Git You Sucka…)


 

So, end result, you have a brief action scene where Leland Orser is shouting out “Bernie!  Casey!  Bernie!  Casey!” and I keep combing the screen, going “Where? Where?”

 


It’s like an Abbott & Costello routine between Kevin Smith and Quentin Tarantino.

 






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

Sam Strange Remembers…CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN

I hate to name-drop, but I used to be friends with Jesus Christ. Back in the 70’s, he often came to my house for breaks from his bum disguise. Once, before we went our separate ways forever (he found out I only liked him because I was scared of his dad), he told me:

“Say, Sam? That friend of yours, Steve Martin? Watch out for him. His great disdain for humanity will soon rob him of his comedic genius.” I just laughed at Jesus and called him naive. Unfortunately, it turns out he was right about Steve Martin. I hope he got the last laugh because none of us did.

So what happened to Steve? Anger. We let him into our hearts because his banjo playing was funny. But once embraced, he shook off this Trojan Horse and demanded we take his banjo playing seriously. We didn’t. And he now scornfully wastes his comedic gift before our very eyes. “You want funny, motherfuckers? I’ll show you funny! Watch this: I’m gonna slip on some marbles and fall face-first into a pie! Assholes!” The opposite of comedy is not tragedy – it’s just shitty comedy. Steve Martin knows this, and he uses it to hurt us. THAT is the tragedy, and it’s all ours.

About seven years ago, Steve wanted a painting, and he needed a cookie-cutter movie to fund it. In an attempt to reconnect with my old friend, I agreed to direct Cheaper by the Dozen. Steve had written it himself. Here is a sample of the script:

——————–

Suburban Mansion (Morning)

ME enters room wearing a suburban robe. ME has a shitload of kids. They’re all a bunch of fucking little monsters like kids in real life.

Something happens to make ME make a funny face. Ad-lib, ad-lib, etc. Funnier face. ME picks up a kid. Kid gets finger paint on ME’S robe.

ME:
Hey, my robe!

Kicked in nutz. Funny pain face.

ME:
Hey, that hurts!

Dances funny. Slips on marbles. Falls down face-first into pie. Slowly lifts pie-face up to look at camera.

Kids run blender with no top. Shit flies everywhere. ME makes funny face of disapproval. Anger ad-lib.

ME:
I can’t believe I have
 so many kids!
(beat)
It’s hard to keep track
of your names!

ME loses temper. Kids cry. A lesson is ad-libbed. ME apologizes for being such a cranky dad. Mom comes home from grocery store.

MOM:
Hey, I know you told me to only
get 10 eggs, but I got 12 because
they’re cheaper that way.

——————–

As you can see, this shit apparently writes it self. So I figured it could direct itself too while I tried to get a tri-generational three-way going with Bonnie Hunt and Hilary Duff. Ultimately, that three-way was the only positive thing to come out of Cheaper by the Dozen. Unless you count the money, and I try to count every cent. It’s probably a very bad film. I didn’t watch it when I made it, and I’m sure as hell not gonna watch it now.

My mission to reconnect with Steve went awry on the first day when I told him to get his twangy fucking banjo out of my face. “Fine!” he pouted. “But you just talked yourself out of tickets to my magic show!” After that I just gave up on him. So should you. It is one of the easier ways to walk in the footsteps of Christ.

(three flaming Frogurts*)

*Joke © Doc Happenin






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

CC: THE COMEDIAN IS OUR RESIDENT CREEP

Probably now best known to fanboys the world over as the Comedian in a little upcoming movie you may have heard about, you know, WatchmenJeffrey Dean Morgan has been cast in Hammer Films’ latest production The Resident. Morgan will co-star along side two-time Oscar-winning babe Hilary Swank.

The Resident centers on a young physician (Swank) who moves into a Brooklyn loft where a series of bizarre events occur more often than not, which, naturally, leads the young woman to believe not all is good and well within her new dwelling. It turns out her landlord (Morgan) is one screwed up puppy, and he isn’t the cool dude he initially appears to be. Seems he’s getting a tad fixated on her.

When the hell are people going to realize moving into New York-based lofts, apartments, or penthouses is a bad idea? Rosemary’s Baby, The Sentinel, anybody?

Anyway, Antti Jokinen, a music video hot shot, will be making his feature-directorial debut on this one. Jokinen co-wrote the script with Robert Orr, which then saw a final pass by Erin Cressida Wilson.

No ETA on a release date for this one, but shooting is slated to get underway this May. Considering it’s a Hammer Film, though, I’ll consider it a miracle if it comes out at all.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

STEP UP 2 THE BOURNE IDENTITY

Despite the snarky title on this article, I’m a big fan of Channing Tatum. I think he’s a powerful actor, and I look forward to the time when he’s getting more serious roles. In the meantime, I’m happy to see him reteaming for a third go round with his A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints writer/director Dito Montiel on an adaptation of The Brotherhood of the Rose, which sounds quite Bournetastic.

I keep getting this book confused with The Name of the Rose, which was adapted into a Christian Slater/Sean Connery buddy monk movie; The Brotherhood of the Rose is about two orphans raised by an espionage agent to be assassins who find themselves targets when they get double crossed. The novel was written by First Blood author David Morrell, and was adapted into an NBC miniseries that starred none other than the great David Morse, way back in 1989.

Montiel, who also wrote and directed Tatum’s next film, Fighting, is writing and directing this one as well. The novel is one part of a loose trilogy, so it’s possible that Warner Bros is looking at this as their post-Bourne era thriller franchise.

Ladies, enjoy the picture of Channing Tatum holding a cock.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

DELLAMORTE DOES BOX OFFICE 1/30/09

I’ve been spending my time watching old and obscure movies. It’s good for the palette. As it were. A Foreign Affair, The Red Ball Express, Play Dirty. Films like this.

THE CAMP PAIN

This week The Reader expands to a thousand screens. It would have last week if anyone involved thought it would get the nominations it did. Oscar nominations usually happen on Tuesday, don’t they? I guess everything felt so locked that it was a safe bet there would be no upsets or surprises, and yet there was upset. Dark Knight fanboys, I know I’m all late on this shit, but TDK is two million shy of having a billion dollar gross and as upset as you might be that the academy that is right about 10% of the time snubbed your masterpiece , realize that they also loved As Good As It Gets, and STFU.

The interesting question of The Reader‘s nominations is this: Will Kate Winslet campaign for her Oscar? I haven’t heard anything yet, but she was dead set on Revolutionary Road being her horse – seeing as how it was directed by her husband. The Academy roundly rejected that title, and so now if she wants the Gold dude in her life, she’s going to have to get that dirt off her shoulder (ladies are pimps too). Which is why I would wager that Anne Hathaway has a clearer shot at it. Meryl Streep has so many awards (and Doubt isn’t the picture), while Angelina Jolie just got the nom because she’s a good actress, but that film was laughed at. Melissa Leo is this year’s Amy Ryan, so she should just be happy with the nomination. Like most races, like most multiple choice questions, the right answer is usually  between two (though sometimes three) choices, and it strikes me this is all about Hathaway – who will have no problems selling herself – and Winslet. It also strikes me that the Academy making the decision they did is actively suggesting Winslet get divorced. Buyer’s remorse on American Beauty perhaps?

An interesting comparison year is 1990, when the nominees were Awakenings, Dances with Wolves, Ghost, The Godfather Part III, and Goodfellas. I can’t imagine if 1990 happened again that we’d have those nominees with people like David Poland and Jeffery Wells working against titles like Awakenings (then again, those guys might be championing something like that). And Ghost was more audience-friendly than something like The Dark Knight. Ghost is such a strange best picture nomination – all I remember about the film is the haircut – though I feel like it got all the nominations it did so the academy could feel good about giving an Oscar to Whoopi Goldberg I feel like The Reader partly got all of those nominations so the academy can feel good about giving Winslet a statue, but you know who won in 1990? Kathy Bates, for a film that had one major nomination as well (Misery).

But when people get upset at Oscar, it’s all about money. It’s about helping pictures that need it, and that’s partly why TDK got left out. People don’t need pushing to see that film, and though every once in a while a film like that wins, the Academy is more about helping films than it is about rewarding blockbusters. Usually. And so The Reader will get at least an additional $20 million out of these noms. And the effect on Button and Slumdog is already apparent. Such is this race.

HEY EVERYBODY! WE’RE ALL GOING TO GET PREDICTIONS!

The most memorable Super-bowl weekend picture I saw was Eye of the Beholder, starring a very naked Ashley Judd and Ewen McGregor, from the director of Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert. I remember walking out and saying “now that is the best film I’ve seen in the last two hours.” This weekend you get Taken, which is out on DVD internationally, I believe, counter-programming with Renee Zellweger in New in Town, and a horror movie starring the hardest working actress in show business, Elizabeth Banks, and the twenty year old Emily Browning (perverts, at least she’s legal now). That movie is The Uninvited. But the main event this weekend with be the TV spots for summer movies (and Watchmen) which will play in between dudes getting up close and personal for the world. This is usually an off weekend, though it’s had its moments. I think the Zellweger picture should eat it, and we may see these pictures falling to Paul Blart: Mall Cop. And Gran Torino, which is a huge-ass hit.

So let’s do it:
1. Taken – $15 Million
2. Paul Blart: Mall Cop – $14.5 Million
3. The Uninvited – $13 Million
4. Gran Torino – $12.8 Million
5. New in Town – $9.5 Million

I have zero faith in the New in Town. So if it’s taken by Hotel for Dogs or Underworld, there’s that.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

TALES OF THE KICK ASS FREIGHTER

Hot on the heels of the disappointing final poster for Watchmen comes this ass-kicking DVD/BD cover for the Tales of the Black Freighter/Under the Hood tie-in. This looks glorious.

Here’s the description of the DVD, which arrives on March 24th:

They’re in the book. And on this disc. From the director of Watchmen and 300 come two tales from the celebrated graphic novel that do not appear in the extraordinary Watchmen Theatrical Feature. Tales of the Black Freighter (featuring the voice of 300’s Gerard Butler) brings to strikingly animated life the novels richly layered story-within-a-story, a daring pirate saga whose turbulent events may mirror those in the Watchmen’s world. Stars from the Watchmen movie team in the amazing live-action/CGI Under the Hood, based on Nite Owl’s powerful first-hand account of how the hooded adventurers came into existence. Two fan-essential stories. One place to watch the excitement. Watching the Watchmen begins here.

Also on this disc will be The Story Within the Story: The Books of Watchmen
and a first look at a Green Lantern cartoon.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

THE WOLVERINE POSTER SAGA

There’s a new poster for X-Men Origins: Wolverine out today, but it’s been a weird little journey to getting there.

First of all, a fanmade poster that circulated a year ago started getting shown as the new poster. Why? Because it somehow ended up on the Fox Press site. I’ve included a screencap of that below. How is it possible that a year old fanmade poster ends up on an official Fox site? Are they stealing fan art now?

That poster, with the claws coming out of the steel, first appeared on the Superhero Hype boards last year. (thanks to Peter from Slashfilm’s Twitter for the link)

This image made the rounds for a little while, but then about two hours ago everybody got an email from Fox’s Press site that contained the real new poster. For some reason IESB is claiming that they have the exclusive on that poster, despite it appearing in every inbox in the land before noon today. Maybe Fox fucked them – it wouldn’t be the first time a studio promised somebody an exclusive only to share the image with everyone. Here’s the new Wolverine poster, of which I honestly have zero opinion. I guess it sort of looks like Wolverine #1 as drawn by Frank Miller.






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email

THUD REVIEW: SUPERNATURAL – "AFTER SCHOOL SPECIAL"


Spoilers.

Supernatural Official Site 

The Time:
Thursdays, 9:00 PM, The CW

The Show:

Sam
and Dean Winchester are two brothers who roam the back roads of America
in a 1967 Chevy Impala hunting evil.  At first they fought all
of the usual: vampires, ghosts, werewolves and the like, but in recent
yeas they’ve found themselves more and more dealing with the literal
forces of Hell as a demon war has been brewing for decades, with their
family caught in the middle.  Sam has been pre-ordained from
birth by a past foe, the yellow-eyed demon, Azazel, to be a pivotal
figure in the war…on the demon side.  Meanwhile, Dean has
recently been resurrected from Hell by angels because they have the Lord’s work
for him to do.

The Stars:

•  Jared Padalecki – Sam Winchester
•  Jensen Ackles – Dean Winchester

The Episode: “After School Special”

Sam and Dean are on the hunt for possibly a demon or a ghost who has possessed several students at a school in Indiana, causing them to kill one student and maim another.  The issue is is that this is a school that Sam and Dean attended for a month 10 years ago when Pops Winchester was off on a hunt.  Via flashbacks, we get to see what high school was like for the young Winchester boys.

The Lowdown:

What can I say?  Another solid episode.  Even more so than usual because we get to see some of the events that helped shape both Sam and Dean and get a further insight as to what life was like for them growing up: always on the road and a new school every few weeks or months.  The kids playing the young Winchesters, especially the young Dean, did spot on jobs, and high school for them is pretty much as you would expect, knowing how Sam and Dean are now.  Also funny to note that since Dean is four years older, how much taller he was than young Sam back then as compared to now.  Sam also had the nickname of “The Midget” from a bully back in the day.  The ghost doing the haunting this episode even made the comment about how much Sam had grown.

The villain this go-round is indeed a ghost, and one that Sam knew back when he attended the school.  Sam of course had issues with wanting to be normal, while Dean reveled in being a free spirit, moving from town to town and school to school.  He was the cool kid and Sam was the geek.  Dean made with the fresh talk to the teachers and was active in the broom closet make out with the local girls.  Meanwhile Sam had several run ins with the local bully, Dirk.

The absolute highlight of the show is of course the undercover roles the Winchesters take when investigating the school.  Sam masquerades as a janitor and Dean becomes the substitute gym teacher, shorts and high-ankle tube socks and all.  He institutes a game of dodge ball and tells a kid to take a lap.  Great stuff.  As for the ghost, there’s  the typical misdirection with whom it is, but when Sam and Dean find out the real identity, and the fact that it’s inhabiting geeks, Sam gets a wave of regret because he had an incident with the ghost as a kid.

If there’s any drawbacks to the episode, it’s the ease with which Dean and Sam are able to just waltz in and assume their roles at the school, explaining away the gym teacher running off to get married.  Seemed a little too convenient, but considering how Dean took to the role, it gets a slide.  The realization of how this particular high school actually was for the boys, and how their roles got reversed was poignant, and the ending scene with Sam and his old teacher left a big question hanging for Sam: Is he happy doing what he’s doing?

This week saw the passing of executive producer and director Kim Manners, who had done some excellent work, both on this show and X-Files, as well as having worked on many shows such as Charlie’s Angels, Automan, Simon & Simon, Star Trek: The Next Generation, 21 Jump Street and The Adventures of Briscoe County, Jr.  He’s directed some of the best episodes of Supernatural, including “Family Remains” and “Mystery Spot.”  His work is what helped to make this show what it is and he will be sorely missed.

8.1 out of 10

Message Board






Author Links: Author's Page · AIM · Twitter · Facebook · Twitter · Email