Most Oscar moments are easily condensed into clips; we saw a bunch of them last night at the show, including the infamous streaker and Cuba Gooding Jr exploding with love (that clip is less wonderful when you’re aware of his career’s future). But last night’s Oscar telecast contained what I thought might have been one of the most wonderful moments in the award show’s history, and it’s one that won’t be easily encapsulated in an out of context clip. It was the moment when John Stewart brought Marketa Irglova back on stage to deliver her acceptance speech for Best Song.
Now, I have a dog in this race. I loved Once, the movie that spawned Falling Slowly. In a sane world that film would have had three nominations, not the trio from Enchanted*, but in the end the victory is all that matters. I began pushing that film from the literal moment that I walked out of the screening room last winter – tears still on my face I pulled out my cell and began calling people to tell them I had just seen the best movie of the year so far (for me it stayed the best for the entire year). What’s amazing about the movie is how it lives inside of me – last night watching the Irglova and Glen Hansard perform the song I actually welled up and got pretty darn emotional. My friend Rachel just sat there laughing at me, but I think that Once is the kind of movie that can become a part of you. It’s the most amazing thing a film can do, but some of them have that power, to get deep into your emotional center and become its own set of stimuli and reactions. Most of the movies that do this are ones that we experienced as kids, and there’s a whole culture of people who seek to stunt their emotional growth by getting misty eyed over The Goonies. Once is a film of such simple beauty and truth that there’s no shame in being misty eyed over it. Hear that, Rachel?
The Oscar producers don’t understand really great moments, which is why Irglova was played off the stage in the first place. All they care about is famous people – George Clooney could win an Oscar and deliver a filibuster and Bil Conti wouldn’t dare raise his stick until hour six. I don’t usually mind the little people being played off – many of the tech people just can’t do public speaking. But Hansard had a great moment – ‘Make art! Make art!’ – and when he handed the mic over after about twenty eight seconds, it had been just cut off completely. Thankfully John Stewart (and the story goes, Colin Farrell, who was backstage demanding that Irglova get to speak) understands what a moment is, and Irglova got her chance to deliver her charmingly unfocused speech.
To me that moment was the highlight of the entire show – a small, unscripted bit where real emotion was allowed to shine through the glitz and pose. That moment was enough to make the other three hours and fifteen minutes worth it.
*by the way, fire whoever staged the first number, Happy Working Song. In the film the song is a parody of how Disney heroines have all the woodland creatures help them do housework; when translated to real world New York City, Amy Adams is assisted by rats, pigeons and a horde of roaches. Having Adams sing that song all by herself on that big stage made it feel like you were watching open mic night at the Winetka Community Center. She needed dancers.





23 comments
pussy
I have to admit, i cheered when they brought her back to give her acceptance speech. A truly awesome moment.
"Fuck you, orchestra."
I was pretty shocked when they skirtted her off stage the first time. I was apllauding from my couch when Jon brought her back out. I haven't seen the film, but the triumph over the "Big Boys" was did pique my interest now.
There wasn't any room on the stage for dancers because Amy Adam's cuteness and adorability filled up every nook and cranny of the joint.
Comment #5 is the dumbest thing I've ever read.
That was the highlight for me as well and a moment I'll actually remember a couple of years from now.
Absolutely the classiest moment of the show.
I just wanted to bang her.
I completely agree that it was wonderful that Marketa was brought back on stage, but what about all the other winners who were played off? When THE BOURNE ULTIMATUM won Best Sound, there were three winners handed statuettes, and only one of them got to say anything before the orchestra cued up and the mic was cut. I loved ONCE and I cheered when Stewart brought Marketa back on stage, but she was only one of a handful of winners last night who were cut off because they weren't famous.
That is cool if it was Colin Farrell was the one who stood up for her. Even if it wasn't him, it was still a GREAT moment. I also considder it different than the other play offs because they were only given like seconds to talk. The others got more time before they were sent on their way.
The "Once" speeches were great, but for me, the comment of the night was when Stewart took a jab at the Vanity Fair folks. They cancel their party "out of respect for the writers", yet they don't give a shit about the writers at all. When they scrapped the party, why couldn't they have just said that they were afraid the big names would boycott the thing, as that was pretty much the concern of everyone throwing these things at the time anyway? Eh, whatever.
That moment was the most memorable from the Oscars, for good and bad. The bad is that no one who stages the Oscars will remember why it was good, that letting her talk and hearing what she said was what made it special. It was special because it wasn't Hollywood. Next year, they'll probably try to recapture it by cutting off Cate Blanchett, and then letting her finish her speech, forgetting that something special like that cannot be manufactured.
Devin bro, do you not care at all that BRAD RENFRO was fucked over by the dear old Academy. Of course they don't want to honor a guy who overdosed on *gasp* heroin, but they have no problem honoring one who died from prescription drugs. You know how dearly I love Heath, but it was total bullshit to snub Renfro.
I hear it was actually Colin Farrell that insisted she be allowed to go back out. Another reason he is emerging as a hero.
Devin… I'm touched that such a benevolent and great man finds the courage within himself to admit to crying after a movie. We are truly blessed to be sharing this world of yours.
Sorry, but I will not let this stand. Devin: it's *Jon* Stewart. And yes, he is just about the classiest comedian in the world.
This almost – *almost* – makes up for Aimee Mann losing to Phil Collins in 2000, which I am still cross about.
I really need to go out and get that "Once" DVD. Sunday night reminded me how much I liked that movie.
My friend told me he saw "Once" and ran out to buy the soundtrack the next day. I chuckled at him openly. Then, I saw the film and raced out to buy the soundtrack the next day. Magic. And their Oscar appearance was similarly wonderful.
"To me that moment was the highlight of the entire show". I agree with you! The best thing of the night.
It wasn't Jon Stewart's idea to bring Irglova back out – it was the show's producer – Stewart was just the messenger.
I actually the moment was when Stewart summed up Glen Hansard:
"That guy is so arrogant."
Once won, so I can like the Oscars again. Until next year.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.