What to do when shills like Peter Hammond get canned, and when lawsuits make creating your own pre-fab quote machines seem like a bad idea? Turn to the IMDB.
To bolster print ads for The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, Disney’s UK arm pulled quotes from user reviews on the IMDB. Not that the Holocaust picture has been getting bad reviews — just the opposite, for the most part — but praise like “Simply stunning” (from Theedge-4) and “Please please see this film” (Mjavfc1) was deemed more compelling than anything the pros had to say. And while Mjavfc1 has only one comment to his credit, Theedge-4 has a discernable track record: likes Satanic Rites of Dracula, doesn’t like The Omen remake, likes Casualties of War. Maybe it’s actually Beaks in disguise.
There’s a lot of ire directed at Disney for this move (and some mis-used jargon, too, as the quoted entities are being called ‘bloggers’, not ‘commentors’) but I’m far more amused than irritated. How can you not laugh at this strategy, which has now garnered more press for the film than anything else the studio is likely to have come up with? And while this is one more open invitation for people to mourn the death of film criticism, doesn’t it really do more to put Hammond and Earl Dittman into perspective than any serious critic?
I haven’t been able to come up with any images of the actual ads, so if any UK readers spot them and can scan or photograph, please send ’em in. I’ll credit either your real name, or your 1337-speak username, however you like.





8 comments
The only way this would be cool is if they were forced to put the imdb link as the source for the pull quote. That way people could go to that link and see things like "0mFg! Th1s movie is teh DEEPZT SUCK LUL U PPL HOO LIKE IT R FARGS HAHAHA" and "oh wow it had jared leto in it and he's like so hot except that one movie he did where he was fat but it just shows he has such a good personality coz like even though hes so sexy he doesnt have to always look hot in his films and omg i wanna marry him, IM mE!!111"
Online news story of the year!! I laughed until I cried, wiped my tears, and then laughed some more! Russ Fischer is the new Devin Faraci!!! The news story to end all news stories regarding pull quotes from IMDB!! I smell pulitzer!! CHUD makes AICN look like a site run by a bald fat retard!!….. Feel free to run with any of these and send my check to my cardboard box. It has the french work "fragile"(I believe it is pronounced fragee-lay) all over it. Thanks!
Magnificent article! A must read! ****!
The only thing I don't get and never have understood, is that it's film criticism. There is nothing that makes some dude on imdb's opinion more valid than Devin Faraci. Why? Because Devin gets paid? At the end of the day they are opinions. Not something you're qualified for due to your extensive study at Harvard. Like say a doctor.
Devin's about as respected and liked as the average imdb poster. And probably fatter.
I never write comments because I often think generally people who do are complete tossers with little constructive to do with their time. The comments above have forced me to break my rule only to point out my initial thoughts were correct. Keep up the good work Russ, Devin and all the people at Chud.
How were the quotes attributed in teh ads? Just generically to IMDB, or to specific users?
It amuses me that people piss and moan about Devin all day long, yet they still come to the site every day. If you don't like what he has to say then don't read his articles you fucking morons. Now go and eat the peanut butter and jelly sandwich your Nana made for you. She cut the crust off just the way you like it. When you're done eating you can go back to her basement/your apartment and pull your dick to the stupid fucking quotes you made on the internet all day long.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.