
Sequels. We hate them because they’re so often just lame retreads of what made the original film so enjoyable in the first place, pale imitations of greatness. Sometimes they’re crazy or weird or their own thing, but most of the time they’re terrible, boring and uninspired. But every now and again a sequel comes out that doesn’t just equal the original, it all but blows it out of the water. It’s rare, but it’s the occasional miracle that keeps us interested in sequels, no matter how much we know better.
These are seven sequels that are better than the original. A few small ground rules: These are all number twos – no third or fourth entries allowed. These are all actual sequels, not vague continuations, prequels or gussied up remakes. They’re standalone movies, not filmed at once as part of a pre-planned trilogy. And these are all great movies on their own.
The Empire Strikes Back – After Empire, Star Wars almost seems quaint. Irving Kershner and screenwriters Leigh Brackett and Lawrence Kasdan open up the Star Wars universe in a major way, and they present exciting new shades of gray into the proceedings. While Lucas’ original film was a reimagining of Flash Gordon serials, Empire feels weightier, bigger and more in line with printed pulpy space opera. Grown up and throwing away the formula, Empire is really the only Star Wars film that works for me anymore.
Bill & Ted’s Bogus Journey – While the original Bill & Ted is filled with wacky charm (the basic concept that all of these historical figures – including two murderous maniacs – would help a couple of dummies pass a school presentation is so delightfully sweet) the sequel opts for the big scale weirdness. Writers Chris Matheson and Ed Solomon could have just had Bill and Ted visiting other eras in history, but this time a metaphysical trip is in order, with Heaven and Hell on the itinerary. And along the way awesome new characters – Station! – join the proceedings, leading up to an ending that I think uses time travel gags much better than the first film.
The Road Warrior – The original Mad Max is a scrappy Ozploitation film (heavily influenced by 1974’s Aussie Stone), but it keeps the end of the world business too far at the margins for my tastes. And it’s essentially an origin story, a sort of vehicular Outback Death Wish. It’s the sequel, The Road Warrior, where Max’s world comes into sharp, eternally defining focus. As does the character of Mad Max, fully transformed into a high wasteland drifter. With a budget comes scope, and George Miller’s vision gets bigger, stranger and more action-packed.
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan – Not just the greatest Star Trek movie, this is the greatest space combat movie of all time. It’s also a movie that understands the characters are just as important as the phaser bolts, and it balances the exciting submarine warfare of two ships in a nebula with the exciting personal warfare of two driven men. Thrilling, fun, sad and gripping, this is everything the lethargic, 2001-inspired Star Trek: The Motion Picture never was.
The Bride of Frankenstein – James Whale thought he couldn’t outdo Frankenstein so he turned this sequel into a semi-comedic take; in fact, watching the film you’ll be surprised at how little Young Frankenstein had to change for the parts it spoofed. And it’s filled with unbelievable oddness, like evil Dr. Praetorius’ collection of tiny people (his own attempts at making life), The Monster’s predilection for a good smoke or the ambiguous nature of Frankenstein and Praetorious’ relationship. But it also manages to be chillingly ugly at moments and ultimately incredibly sad. The Monster proves to be totally emo and unable to take rejection from his Bride (played with hissingly good theatrics by Elsa Lanchester), but you understand where he’s coming from. Dude just wants a friend and a smoke. It’s the interplay of comedy and horror and tragedy that makes Bride of Frankenstein easily the best of all Frankenstein movies.
A Shot in the Dark – This sequel to The Pink Panther came out three months after the original. And it was never intended to be a sequel to The Pink Panther. But it is the film that creates the world of Inspector Clouseau that we all know – it was here that Peter Sellars took his accent way over the top, and it was here that Dreyfus and Cato were introduced. In fact, it could be argued that A Shot in the Dark is the first real Pink Panther movie (even though the Pink Panther is not in it or, if I recall, even mentioned). It’s also a lot funnier than The Pink Panther, if a little broader. But Clouseau at the nudist colony or playing pool with a wickedly warped cue are the kinds of gags that appealed to me as a kid watching the films on TV and still appeal to me now. And beyond all that, A Shot in the Dark has Elke Sommer, and we all know that films with Elke Sommer are better than films without her.
The Godfather, Part II – Not just the best sequel ever but possibly the best film ever made, Francis Ford Coppola’s stunning masterpiece doesn’t so much blow The Godfather out of the water as it stands on that film’s shoulders and ascends into the heavens. Building on the rich, complex world and characters of the first film, Coppola shrewdly moves forward while looking back, contrasting the rises of two generations of Corleones. The depth of the film is staggering, as is the craft; at this point Coppola was firing on all cylinders, just before blowing out on Apocalypse Now, and he simply nails every single moment. The reality is that even the best movies I see in any given year aren’t half as good as The Godfather, Part II.





66 comments
I was waiting, semi-worriedly, to see whether GFII would appear, as we all know that, as the best film of all time, it is certainly the best sequel of all time.
Good article Dev. People will argue about "Aliens" – but I've always thought "Alien" was the best movie, by far.
I was a little worried after seeing the Arnie pic that that pile of shit called Conan the Destroyer was going to be on this list. Way to fuck with my head Devin.
It is nice to see Bogus Journey getting some love.
Thank you for not mentioning TERMINATOR 2. I've always felt the original was way better.
great, great list…really surprised Bourne Supremacy did not make the list. Coming from an excellent spyaction flick to a character pieceaction movie in which the guy we were rooting for in the first film, may actually be one fo the most cold hearted assassins. Great series.
Magic Kenny, agree on the Alien sentiment. It is both one of my favorite sci fi AND horror movies. Other possibilities include: Evil Dead 2, Supercop, Dawn of the Dead. Toy Story 2?
dark knight's not on here…THAT'S A BIG SURPRISE. it's also nice to hear devin talk about something star wars related and have it not filled with geeky self-hate.
but i kid with you, devin. this is a pretty great list of movies
I'd add Superman II.
Either version.
Really cool list, would like to see more of these better sequels type deals.
Shit, I thought I was the only one who thought Bogus Journey was better than Excellent Adventure. Nice to see I'm not alone.
A Shot in the Dark is fantastic and a great pick.
Thank God 'Aliens' isn't on that list. While it's a good movie it's also just miltary hardware wank, totally took away from the mythos of the beast when loads of these 'perfect organisms' were just popped like water balloons by the big guns. No Spider-Man 2 though?
umm… Blade 2???
Babe: Pig in the City- seriously! Better than the first. If you haven't seen it don't be a hater.
Fuck Spiderman 2. All these movies at least had to try to surpass the original film's quality. Spidey 2 was just everything spidey 1 should have been from the start but they punked out on it. And where's X2 while we're on the subject of comicbook films. I can see why the dark knight's not on there. It wasn't hard to beat batman begins. I don't care what anyone says Prizoner of Azkaban should be on here. That's the only potter movie worth a shit.
I have not seen A Shot in the Dark… but they way you describe seems to go against the ground rules you set up. f it was not meant to be a sequel and doesn't even reference the original, doesn't that fall into the vague continuation category?
I can't believe you left Mannequin 2: On the Move off your list. Your shame runs deep, Devin.
Hell no Superman 2 doesn't belong on here. Also surprised Devin didn't add two of his personal favorites (Bourne Supremacy and Spiderman 2) of the last decade here as well.
Blade 2 doesn't belong here either. Dark Knight is a superior sequel but getting Devin to put that on his list is like getting Oliver Stone to make a film praising Bill O'Reilly.
No "Breakin' 2: Electric Boogaloo"?
I'll be honest, except for the sequences featuring the history of Don Corleone, Godfather 2 is pretty fucking dull.
Devin, great list! My goth! Star Trek II 'and' The Road Warrior both came out in the summer of 1982. Damn.
I'd have to disagree about the second Mad Max picture. The Roadwarrior, though more fantastical and broad in scope, just doesn't have the out-and-out idiosyncratic detail (the district attorney walking around with kendo gear?) combined with ridiculous amounts of personality (the Nightrider, Johnny the Boy, The Goose, and the motherf#cking Toecutter?!?). Sure, it doesn't have the post-apocalypse grandeur of The Roadwarrior but the second movie also doesn't have very many locations and isn't as colorful or stylish as the first Mad Max either. Then again, what do I know, I also like Beyond Thunderdome more than the Roadwarrior (and get accused of being a cretin for it quite often).
Whoever said Prisoner of Azkaban – this list is only for number 2s. A great list Devin, I will argue all day to my nerd friends about what a classic Wrath of Khan is. Empire still pisses over anything else Star Wars. I do think Aliens is a very good film and would make a good number 11 though.
The Godfather series needs to get bent. I'd rather watch Suburban Commando.
uh, Babe 2? I'll watch that five times to every one time I'll watch Road Warrior.
Oliver Stone will make a film praising Bill O' Reilly. I'm telling you.
I second Blade 2
Bad News Bears In Breaking Training?
Props for not going for the predictable usual crap that gets trotted out on this subject Devin, the old Spiderman, X-Men, Bourne-men triumverate.
NOT THE DARK KNIGHT!
I jest, an excellent list and all films i love to death. Kudos on the Mad Max front, the 1st film really is nothing but an exploitation film, the second is just a classic action film general.
No votes for Hellboy 2? Where's the Guillermo love?!?! Shot in the Dark is the best nod on this list.
Blade 2, really? I remember being so disappointed after reading all the hype. Much prefer the first one.
I sort of figured Road Warrior would be better. I found Mad Max sort of dull, but strangely, I've always wanted to see the sequel anyway. I was sure Toy Story 2 would be on this. I prefer Godfather part 1 a lot more. Part 2 is one big second act and not as interesting. Still have yet to see part 3.
The Road Warrior and A Shot In The Dark I completely agree with. I love The Empire Strikes Back, but see it as piece of a larger story myself. I'm surprised Toy Story 2 and Aliens weren't on the list. Those are both incredible sequels. The Bride of Frankenstein I actually dislike quite a bit–mainly because of the weird comedic tone of the film; it just didn't work for me. And maybe I'm in the minorty, but I actually prefer The Godfather to it's sequel. I've seen the second one 4 or 5 times, and still find it's pace to be too lethargic. The original Godfather was more focused and had a better-developed storyline and characters. Godfather Part II is a decent film, but nowhere near as great as the original, IMO.
Wow, no love for Teen Wolf Too! Ridiculous.
I know we are jokin about it and all but let's face it, it's ridiculous the Dark Knight isn't on this list. Devin has even commented in the past that Begins doesn't really work at the end of the day and TDK is a superior film. In fact it might even be a better leap of quality from the original than any other film on this list. Although that's arguable with The Road Warrior.
Great choices. Expected to see Toy Story 2, Gremlins 2 and Evil Dead 2. Maybe it needed to be a top 10 list.
I think Devin wanted the alliteration. Otherwise seven is a pretty arbitrary number.
Great list, Devin. The inclusion of Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey was very station. There are some obvious choices included there: Road Warrior, ESB, Godfather 2 & Khan… as well as some obvious ones missing: Dark Knight, Superman 2, Evil Dead 2 and Toy Story 2. Imagine my disappointment, though, at finding no Weekend at Bernie's 2 on the list?
I love Evil Dead 2, but it's really a remake, and therefore disqualified. Also glad to see I'm not the only one who thinks GF1 was the best of the three.
A few years ago I would have argued that SUPERMAN II belonged on this list. But after watching it again, it doesn't hold up well for me, and it is certainly nowhere near the majesty of SUPERMAN THE MOVIE.
I much prefer the original Evil Dead over the Sequel. Aliens I think really isn't a true sequel just another tale of the same life forms. Road Warrior for me is similar as Aliens. Not a true sequel, but continuation of the world that Max lives in.
bogus journey was ok but i wouldn't say that it was better then the original. but i have to agree with you on the rest. would like to have seen evil dead 2 in this one, but if you would consider that a remake, the i'll go with army of darkness. love the articles keep em up. PS. ANY WORD ON A NEW GODZILLA MOVIE?
Bill and Ted and Pink Panther over Aliens and The Dark Knight!? Are you serious?
I watched some of the Pink Panther movies, including A Shot in the Dark, over the last year on HDNet Movies. I remember liking them when I was a kid, but on rewatching them I realized they are all complete turds. Practically unwatchable.
Reading this list makes me sad that Nick Cave's proposed 'Gladiator' sequel won't get made.
I can watch A Shot in the Dark any time it's on. I'm also impressed with your inclusion of Bogus Journey, although I do have to ask: What about Gremlins 2? It's not just a good sequel, but it's an insane little slice of meta. To me, it's a fitting companion piece to Bogus Journey, a weird sequel that goes off in entirely unexpected directions that also confounds fans of the original film. Batman Returns kinda fits the mold, too. For years, I got a bunch of shit from my friends for liking Returns better than the original Burton Batman, but they've come along recently.
Bogus Journey is great in so many ways and definitely better than Excellent Adventure. I'm surprised no mention was made about William Sadler as the Grim Reaper. He is the best part of that movie although Station is pretty great too. "Best 4 out of 7"… "You sunk my battle ship"….. classic
Superman II was a pre-fab sequel that was in production at the same time as the first movie. Otherwise, I would agree that it should be on the list.
Blade 2 – YES! vampires that kill/scar the crap out of other vampires blow Stephen Dorf out of the water on his best day.
The Dark Knight – NO! overblown, Michael Mann-wannabe (without anywhere near the talent for shooting action), even worse third act than Batman Begins, bullshit pseudo-political rhetoric! fuck that movie! ledger is the only thing worthwhile, and they gave him some real shit dialogue to work with, so it really speaks to his talent. Michael Caine too!
Spiderman 2 – YES! dumb origin story out of the way, now an actual story can happen – and it's fucking great!
X2 – no… just, no.
if star wars and star trek movies go on the list, then Terminator 2 and Dark Knight are good stand alones as well.. though their predecessors are good, these are better..
I like the list, but I'm also torn of what is truly the best sequel ever made. The xclusion of The Dark Knight is a mistake, but IMHO its a trifecta to be honest — Empire Strikes Back — Star Trek II — Godfather Part Two. All are on the same plateau of quality. For me those are the templates. Now a harder list would be to countdown the 3's in a given franchise, because most just blow chunks.
Devin I think you hit most of the films right on the head. What is the purpose of a sequel? Revenue of the first film aside, I think a sequel is nothing more than a stopgap for those who simply can't let the characters go. And that certainly includes the author/creator. I think a successful sequel shouldn't just expand upon the original motif, but take it in new directions. Show the viewer something they know and then pull the rug out from under them. A truly great sequel lets you sample a taste of the familiar and then throws you down the rabbit hole of the unknown.
Weird that I was thinking about SW and ESB this week. I think Empire is by far a better film, but Star Wars is a more perfect movie. I like Star Wars better because everything that happens is important. After having seen both 100+ times, I can no longer watch Empire after they leave Hoth, I almost always watch all of Star Wars. There's something to be said for the fact that it has an ending too.
Fuck Aliens. There, I said it.
That's what makes Empire so remarkable… pardon me, but I'm about to get all passionate here… The film takes on the nearly impossible task of surpassing the quality of the first star wars and not only does that but elevates it to a level on par with more mature and complex films, at least as far as the 80s goes. I'm only 23 but I understand that it must have been something amazing back then to see sequel as good as ESB. Just look at how many fail to come close to the original movie. I watch ESB now too as the only star wars movie worth watching for its sheer filmmaking excellence. The movie flows perfectly, the chamber duel still builds up to a stunning conclusion no star wars film has re-captured since then, the dialogue is some deep shit, it's just a fluke of a movie.
Blade 2 probably should be on there but I understand the argument for it not being there. Tone-wise, that film teeters either on the side of horror or camp for too long before falling headfirst onto the camp side. Granted, the camp in Blade is nowhere near as bad as Batman and Robin but Blade 2 is still just a little too cartoony to be on the list. Especially with all those CGI stunt doubles.
I admit though that I am a little surprised at the lack of Predator 2 being mentioned on the list though. I don't think people loved that film as much as they should have and honestly I feel it as a film blows those damn AVP movies to pieces. Predator 2 has great style, perfect music and the perfect combination of Glover, Paxton, Busey, and Blades. What's not to like? At least it wasn't PG-13!
Plus, Stephen Hopkins has made some really good movies in addition to Predator 2 (no, I'm not including Lost In Space!). I could watch Judgment Night, Blown Away, Ghost And The Darkness, and Under Suspicion everyday for a week and never get bored!
I second "Hellboy 2", the first one was just ok, but the second one had me thinking about it for days afterwards. I'd also mention "Hellraiser", which seemed far superior to "Hellbound" IMO, and scarred the crap out of me. But what the hell do I know, I liked "Chronicles of Riddick"…
Why even write this article? It's a list article, which is basically the last bastion of someone with nothing to fucking say, and it has not one single interesting or exciting choice. Basically everyone has already reached those conclusions already.
Waste of time, waste of bandwidth.
Why not?
Seriously, there's a larger context to Devin's articles. In this case sequels are a topic that come up often here.
Furthermore I"ve never seen Bride of Frankenstein, but I will now. If just one person finds something new to enjoy, I don't see how this article could be a waste.
I've rarely been steered wrong by this site.
Karate Kid Part 2 …..seriously
hellraiser 2
Hellboy 2 is a piece of shit.
Dark Knight is technically Batman 6 not Batman 2, so it doesn't apply. Also, I think Terminator 2, though it is awesome, is more like a remake of the first than a sequel. What about Elephant? It takes Gerry and expands on the ideas and scope like a good sequel should.
after endless hours of thinking, batman movies have been redone 3 times.. But Terminator 2 is a true sequel.. John and sarah are 12-16 years older, new robots carry out a different plot, the sequel brings home 4 oscars.. but sci-fi action movies are always oscar bait -.-
You forget Ewoks – The Battle for Endor. It's really the only Ewok movie that works for me anymore.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.