Has the future finally arrived?
I’ve been saying for a while that physical media is on its way out and that digital download is the way of the future (way of the future), but there have been some serious stumbling blocks keeping that future from happening. One of the most pernicious was the lack of standards – you could buy a movie on your iPhone, which was cool, but you could only watch it on the phone. You could get the latest Hollywood hit movie or TV show on your Xbox, but it was stuck on that hard drive. Sure, Blu-Rays and DVDs come with digital copies now, but you have to rip them to your computer before loading them on some other device, a process that’s probably beyond most people (I’ve never even bothered attempting it).
Disney is attempting to surmount this problem using their new KeyChest authentication system. The basic gist of KeyChest is this: you buy a movie and you can watch it on your Xbox, your TV, your phone, your computer, your device that has not yet been invented. And there are no digital copies or hard discs to worry about – the movie is stored on a central server and you access it anytime, anywhere that you like. It’s not just Disney movies, either – the goal of KeyChest is that every movie you buy, from every studio and every distribution channel, will be hooked up together using this authentication system.
There are many of you who are against this immediately just because you’re attached to physical media. There’s a good chance that if you’re on CHUD you’re a collector and you like having that shelf full of DVDs and Blus. The reality is that most people don’t feel the same way. As we learned with the digital distribution of music, it’s the product that matters, not that packaging (and we also learned that people would happily trade sound quality for convenience, by the way). But as we learned with digital distribution of music, this doesn’t mean the end of physical media. The vinyl LP has made a surprising comeback in the last few years, to the point where I’ve seen them sold in Barnes & Noble. This is because there are still niche audiences that want to buy the format, and the corporations will continue to sell to those niche audiences. As long as enough of us want a physical box set of The Godfather Trilogy, Paramount will make a physical box set of The Godfather Trilogy.
KeyChest still faces some stumbling blocks: bandwidth remains an issue. That said, I believe that once the American public sets their sites on video on demand the bandwidth will suddenly appear – we got a man on the moon, we can probably figure out how to get bigger pipes to the boonies so that giant media conglomerates can sell us stuff. There are over-the-air issues, but again, I think these will be solved in the near future. I suspect that by 2020 the ubiquity of the internet will be stunning – wifi will be everywhere, and cheap or free. And our phones will be on at least 4G networks, maybe even 5G. The access will increase as the demand does.
But beyond the stumbling blocks, there are basic questions about KeyChest and digital downloads in general that must be answered. What does ownership mean in the digital download era? Can George Lucas take away my digital copies of Star Wars when he wants to upgrade the FX again? Will I still be able to store these digital copies on fixed media, just in case I’m in a place without wifi, like a plane or on a camping trip? And will KeyChest itself include physical media – will the Blu of Wrath of Khan I buy at Best Buy have a KeyChest code in the booklet so that I can add it to my collection in the computing cloud, meaning I can have Khan while on the road but keep the disc at home?
These questions are small but niggling ones, and they have to be addressed at some point. Disney hopes to get KeyChest up and running by the end of the year; there will be additional partnerships announced in a few months. Some companies will bristle against this, as they want proprietary formats – I bet Apple doesn’t play ball – and some studios prefer to make you buy a copy of a movie for your living room and one for your phone. But this is the way home entertainment media ownership is going, and just like people who stood by pan and scan and people who stood by DIVX got steamrolled, so will anyone who gets in the way of a digital download model that allows consumers ultimate flexibility. I don’t know that KeyChest is the killer app that gets digital download off the ground in a major way, but it’s certainly a major step in the right direction.





17 comments
Devin, you're gonna be on a campin' trip, communin' with the nature and you're worried about taking yer movies?
I actually just finished selling 500ish DVDs after ripping/encoding them all. Took about 4 months to do. I love not having two huge bookshelves cluttering up my apartment now. Plus with a media center browsing through titles is more enjoyable than looking through a shelf of DVDs.
I hope this system works out for Disney. Would be nice to have an 'official' option!
Netflix streaming is good for me. I won't pay DVD price for a download on a movie-by-movie basis. A subscription service that gives me access to multiple movies, however, works.
#2
just a quick question, because i've considered the same thing, and i'm curious. what happens if your media server and/or hard drive crashes? those 500 movies are pretty much toast at that point.
i'd love to have my four bookshelves of dvds digitized, but that's been keeping me from it for a while now.
I wish people would stop saying digital download. All downloads are digital. The term is digital distribution.
Haha @ #1. Movie collections on camping trips INDEED.
Wouldn't Apple want to broker a deal, as Steve Jobs is on the Board of directors for Disney?
Also, that "ubiquity of internet" you're talking about means more, stronger signals for your devices to pick up. Imagine a TV that can access the internet way the hell up in the mountains whilst camping. Same thing with planes. Like you say, the demand will increase the access.
I'm all for eliminating DVDs just like I eliminated CDs as long as two things happen.
1)As devin said, make sure I can watch it on whatever device I want and not have to worry about harddrive space and 2) Get everything I have now as a download. I don't want to be stuck with only new releases and the top hits. I want my films like Boss Nigger, Attack of the Mushroom People and Aligator too. Give me my trash or I stick with DVDs.
I'm 26 years old, and I still hate iPods. Give me a damn CD! I will never buy a digital copy of a movie. When the internet is fried and you all have computer viruses, I will still be watching my DVDs and Blue Rays.
I agree. I'm getting sick of all this shit cluttering up my place. Even my most favorite/oft watched movies get an airing only once a year at best. TV is great right now, but it makes it less like the years where you clung to shows after the fact against the cold winter of poor content. Who are we archiving this shit for anyway? Our families don't want this crap – it'll all go into a skip if you happen to fall under a bus.
You think there'll still be a human race in 2020? You don't strike me as an optimist.
Devin I agree I see this coming too. I said it about video games too the first time companies started offering DLC, and I thought shit we aren't going to be buying discs anymore. which to me is a shame. Don't ask why but I need the physical object. It's just not really there if I can't hold it in my hands or put it on my shelf. Yeah I got a lot of clutter because of this but I at least i got something. servers can get hacked, crashed, and your paying for a monthly service to view something you have already purchased. Now your just starting to bend over them.
This is the scenario corporations want- it's all physically under their roof and they let you rent, ha, ha, yeah, I mean, "own" it. With the trends of available of media storage capacity always headed in the direction of more and cheaper, why would you want to have to pull something through a pipeline every time you wanted to watch it or listen to it? I'll admit, I've cut down on the crap I own; it's just not necessary to own every piece of crap that you've seen. My stupid DVR already goes belly up when it's disconnected from big brother cable company, which leads me to ponder, why do I bother recording all this stuff, if when the cable goes down, it suddenly doesn't exist. Guess what comes out then, yep, good ole' DVDs. Frankly, if they make it convenient enough, people will do it, it's only when it's inconvenient do people make a stand anyway. Someday they'll make you pay to access your own memories, and if it's convenient, you'll sign up for it. You know you will.
To the guy who is worrying about losing all of his movies if he digitizes them, I more or less got around that by setting up my hard drives in a mirrored RAID format. You can look it up for an in-depth description, but the basic idea of it is that you have two hard drives of the same size, and everything that gets put onto one hard drive automatically gets copied to the other one. If one of the hard drives dies, the other one still contains all of the info and will work until you replace the dead drive. When you replace the dead drive, the new (blank) drive gets populated with all of the info that was on the other drive. This is a pretty good way of protecting yourself against data loss. I put all of my pictures and a lot of my movies/TV shows on there.
I won't complete ownership of whatever I purchase – personal usage, anyway. I want to be able to buy a song and use that on any product I own, including in any Rock Band or Guitar Hero game. If I buy rights to a movie, I want them in perpetuity. Even better would be if you buy a game (or movie), then you also get that same usage with any music on its soundtrack.
Sounds interesting, and…. wait, I want that TRON Mickey Mouse!
Nice Aviator reference, Devin.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.