Yesterday I was pissed off because I wasn’t able to see Legion.
Today I’m pissed off because I was.
Considering the rich tapestry of possibilities that exist in stories of wars between the denizens of Heaven and Mankind, Legion has no right being as much of a dumb mess that it is. But dumb and messy it is, which is surprising considering the panorama of reliable performers in the cast.
The brainchild of special effects guru Scott Stewart, the film tells the story of Michael (Paul Bettany), an angel who rebels against Heaven’s decision to obliterate humanity after we as a race have disappointed God to the point of Apocalypse. He retreats to Earth, cuts off his wings [which is dumb, you’ll discover], and grabs a whole bunch of machine guns to defend an unborn child from hordes of humans under control of the forces of evil angels led by the villainous Gabriel (Kevin Durand). Michael winds up at a shitty old diner in the middle of the desert where he and the patrons are besieged by the most useless villains I’ve seen in theaters for quite some time.
We’ll get back to that.
There are some interesting moments in Legion. Though it’s telegraphed and overused in the film’s marketing, there’s a really fun scene where an old woman with a walker becomes ‘possessed’ and walks on the ceiling. There are a few moments where Paul Bettany is able to deliver the oftentimes arch dialogue and sell the idea that all this could or would possibly happen. Charles S. Dutton tries his best to play the part of lovable redshirt. The Doug Jones Ice Cream Man character is cool, until…
…he’s gunned down immediately after his legs grow long. He shows up, looks cool, and harmlessly dies.
That’s the real problem here, a few decent visual ideas that are tied together with the loosest bit of narrative possible. So many elements of the story are ill conceived and threadbare, it’s impossible to give a damn about anyone. Our heroine is a pregnant girl who smokes cigarettes [the biggest sin of all!] and bitches. Our hero is Lucas Black, a pushover who doesn’t like to work and lets himself be bossed around by his dad, Dennis Quaid. He’s also a loser. Charles S. Dutton is a short-order cook with a hook for a hand. We do not know how he lost the hand but it’s a good bet it involved mistakes. Tyrene Gibson is a recovering thug trying to regain his child in a divorce. He’s a loser too! Jon Tenney, Willa Holland [hot!], and Kate Walsh are a rich family of losers. The film is populated with absolute deadbeats, all of whom get holed up in this diner with the loser angel as they face a boring onslaught.
If this is Armageddon, I’m not scared. How the end of humanity takes shape is that human beings get taken over, do the little Jacob’s Ladder thing with their heads, grow sharp teeth, and do absolutely nothing. There are many scenes of these empty people getting shot by machine gun fire, but for the most part they exist only to take up space and serve as squib carriages. There’s also a useless swarm of locusts.
It truly is a poorly realized amateurish mixture of The Prophecy and Preacher, but with absolutely no identity of its own and not enough depth to even warrant a ‘leave your brain in the car’ viewing. It’s not even very good eye candy, surprising coming from a guy whose work with the FX house The Orphanage should have provided some merit.
And the climax is truly rancid.
Yeah, skip this one. You’ll be thankful.





44 comments
It was pretty obvious that it was most likely a horrible film. You should stop putting yourself through all this midnight and extended aggravation for such movies.
This had just about the worst trailer of the last few years, so it's no surprise that this would be such an pathetic failure.
So this week we get Legion, The Tooth Fairy and Extraordinary Measure. Fuck you, God!
Strange. I've seen this and thought it was the best movie i've seen this year. Okay, I've only seen this and Avatar this year but we're only in January.
Don't you think an apology to Regal is in order, Nick?
NO ONE'S GONNA TELL ME HOW TO RUN MY LAB
BEST. OPENER. EVER.
After all you went through last night, I'm sorry to hear that it didn't pay off with Legion.
I can't stand when movies try to make monsters look "scary" by having them scream their mouths open unnaturally long. That fucking Ice Cream Man does that in the trailer, and I want to set fire to the screen when I see it. STOP IT, HOLLYWOOD
Yeah, when I saw the previews for this I figured I'd probably be better off staying home and Netflixing The Prophecy
Why is this the pick of the week? Also, how in god's name could you have expected anything better. This was guaranteed shit from the first trailer.
IT sucked for sure but it also felt like a Demon Knight rip off too, right down to the tattoo switching places.
You did it! Bless your nutsack, Mr. Nunziata. Appreciate you pushing this review out.
Don't you feel stupid now for wasting however long it took for you to write that rant? I would feel stupid…
Glad to do it for my readers. Might have saved someone's Friday night. And also helped them to pick the right place TO see a flick. Proud to help out. Go fuck yourself.
I find this a little sad cause I thought the trailer had a " looks so stupid it's going to be awesome" vibe. Oh well. Sometimes when you know the trailer is stupid & it's crappy/dangerous out, & you're in a bad mood you might want to consider that something is telling you to just stay home.
Nick you need to heal your wounds with a bottle of Lagavulin 16yr and a stogie. Good for the soul.
4 out of 10, Devin?
Are you out of your fucking mind? What in this movie deserved 4? ANYTHING? I'll admit Paul Bettany managed to maintain a cool presence and is the one actor in this shitfest that I didn't wish AIDS upon the moment the credits rolled, but this movie is fucking horrible. I hope "Priest" is better, because Bettany has a future in the action roles and I'd like to see him land something that wasn't so completely half assed as this piece of shit.
" Squib carriages. " That's beautiful, man.
You saved me $8. Thank you.
Is there any chance your review may have been slightly tainted by the problems you had seeing this?
Or is it really that bad?
I only ask because your review seemed shorter and less humorous than usual.
And the 4/10 rating does seem high compared to the text.
If this movie was so bad, why did it earn "Pick of the Week!" status?? Please make sure ya'll watch the films BEFORE giving them an endorsement.
But how was this ever going to be good? The moment I read the plot I totally dismissed it.
So Im wondering… could GOD have been trying to stop you seeing this Nick? lol
I had little hope for this film, but apparently my expected twist of "the baby Michael is trying to protect is actually the Antichrist" didn't pan out; and thus my status of "rental" is cancellled.
This merits "Pick of the Week" because its competition was Extraordinary Measures and the fucking Tooth Fairy. Compared to that, this has to look like a classic.
So basically, couldn't God have taken over a cruise missile launching site and blown the diner up with a Tomahawk instead? He can do that sort of thing because he's God after all.
what a wretched weekend for movies.. theres bigger reasons for Avatars success other than inflated 3D ticket prices..
@24: I had that hope as well. Bastards!
Isn't this sort of what's going on in Supernatural right now? minus a pregnancy or two.
correct me if i'm wrong but didnt buffy end up up in a deserted diner while running from baddies trying to bring about the end already?
I was interested in this when I first read about it untill I learned he spends the majority of the movie fighting with guns. GUNS?! He's an archangel, fighting demons, why is he using guns like a common action movie?! Totally ruined my expectation, and it seems I was right to be avoiding this. Thanks, Nick.
This fall I was so pumped for a January filled with fun genre pics like DAyBREAKERS, BOOK OF ELI, LEGION, & EDGE OF DARKNESS. But as I got closer they all looked like Redbox candidates. So far I haven't heard anything to change my mind. Still looking forward to FROM PARIS WITH LOVE, that's clearly too retarded to watch drunk the night before the Super Bowl.
Regal was looking out for you by canceling the midnight showing you were so upset that you missed. You shouldn't have forsaken the Regal, the Regal is an angry god. The Regal has punished you by taking precious moments of your life away with this piece of trash. The Regal wants an apology.
When I saw pictures of angels holding uzis I also expected a masterpiece. You dummy.
The fight scene between Michael and Gabriel was amazing… it was everything that the fight between Anakin and Obi-Wan should have been… also, I wouldn't base my viewing this movie or not viewing this movie because of Nick… he is a pretty jaded soul when it comes to all things spiritual…
I could really give a shit about peoples expectations with this one. I went in with expectations low and was pretty entertained. Bettany and Durand were great and the action while not very original was serviceable. Its not bonkers or insane based on the trailer but I like a good siege film (Assault on Precinct 13 original mind you) and this was a good time. This is a perfect little saturday night action romp. It beats some of the films glorified around this site. I will say this it needed more rocket launchers and Angels though.
#35 all things spiritual? so this movie is spiritually enforcing? and star wars is popular in the christian community i bet, nothing out of place with that..
Sounds an awful lot like several episodes from past seasons of Supernatural. Yeah, #35: you must be trippin'…if this is your idea of spiritual then just fuck you in your soul, your fucking assoul. & #18: Devin?
#37: yes, this movie is spiritually enforcing… just read your Old Testament… the Star Wars comment? are you kidding me?, it's not like I am muslim… #38: you have such an astute argument, how could I not be dissuaded?… just a little time with spell check and Asbury Seminary here you come…
hey tell that fuck hold douche bag that is still crying about being picked on in the sixth grade devin that im gladd he cut out the article of shutter island because of my comment. you will and have and will again always be a douche devin. you contradict like ebert. your site is up only because people love contraversy. but thank you for taking down the article becuse of me 😉 ps…your curls look like you belong in anne of green gables
Wow, some same-old crazy with some all-new crazy. So, Legion sucks huh?
i agree fullhearted with everyone but go easy, hollywood doesnt have a lot of new ideas nowadays, they dont have the brain power. legion sucks admittedly but the whole "god is going to kill eveyone" thing is actually kind of … WHAT AM I TYPING!!! it sucks, no excuse!
i agree fullhearted with everyone but go easy, hollywood doesnt have a lot of new ideas nowadays, they dont have the brain power. legion sucks admittedly but the whole "god is going to kill eveyone" thing is actually kind of … WHAT AM I TYPING!!! it sucks, no excuse!
the storyline is fucking stupid!!!
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.