
In the same Variety article that reveals that Universal is planning a fourth Bourne movie with Matt Damon and Paul Greengrass, we discover that the studio was more than a little shocked to find out that Guillermo del Toro is looking to be the guy to direct the two Hobbit movies for New Line:
U also was caught off-guard after they aggressively courted Guillermo
Del Toro, the filmmaker behind “Pan’s Labyrinth” and “Hellboy.” The
studio gave him a first-look deal, picked up a sequel to “Hellboy” with
a budget of more than $80 million, and even bought the rights to his
dream project, the H.P. Lovecraft epic, “At the Mountains of Madness.”
But U brass was stunned to suddenly see Del Toro emerge as the
likely director of the next two “Hobbit” movies for New Line and MGM.
That would lock him down for four straight years in New Zealand.
Langley acknowledges, “We’re in discussions with how to rectify that with Guillermo.”
This whole thing leaves me feeling torn in half. On the one hand, doing the two Hobbit movies will give GdT the muscle and ability to get anything he wants made for the next few years, and it’ll certainly be a terrific payday for a guy who deserves one. On the other hand, these movies will take GdT out of circulation for four to five years, right in the middle of what is starting to look, after Pan’s Labyrinth, like his prime moviemaking years. Guillermo’s a filmmaker who has blossomed into undeniable greatness, and I’d love to see him pursuing his vision rather than working in somebody else’s sandbox. That said, the idea of Guillermo bringing his sensibility to The Hobbit and the bridge film are pretty exciting.
Of course the deal for The Hobbit isn’t sealed yet. GdT has found himself with the classic Alex P Keaton dilemma, too many dates to the dance, and it’ll be interesting – and possibly career defining – to see how he handles it.





16 comments
I think his greatness as a filmmaker is still pretty damn deniable. As a designer of neat looking things that special effects groups can make look pretty cool, he's the bee knees, though.
Three Oranges, I don't think your comment came out the way you wanted it too. It really makes no damn sense, but I think I got it.
If GDT chooses to make the Hobbit films, I hope Universal will let him. I know how these studio director conflicts usually turn out, and it's never good. Still I hope to see Mountains sooner rather then later. But whatever his next film is, I will be first in line.
Good work Devin.
I've worked with Guillermo before and I love the guy to death. His enthusiasm, his imagination and his personality are all so endearing, but as a filmmaker he's yet to knock it out of the park for me. I saw Pan's late in the game, but after all the CHUD and AICN hyping I found it to be so incredibly overrated. The first Hellboy was the same. Hyped to death by all the fanboys, but it was such a let down. His films are enjoyable and inventive, but I'd never revisit them and I can't understand the insane amount of fanboy love this guy gets. His movies are always on the cusp of being great, but never quite get there in my opinion. Lovely guy, though.
Three Oranges's comment made perfect sense. Not saying I agree or disagree, but I understood exactly what he was saying, Solomon.
Maybe you were confused because you didn't realize bees had knees.
I think everyone sees the absolutely massive amount of potential in GDT. Seems like that's what many people are in awe of. Also, he brings so much passion, humor, and heart to every project he works on. I love that he wears his heart on his sleeve as a director. Personally, I would prefer it if he didn't spend time on the Hobbit movies. I think he would do a fantastic job, but all that time could also be spent showing us his vision on other projects that aren't quite as much in the public consciousness as Tolkien's stories.
Guillermo's movies always turn out to have no purpose, other than for being a two hour special effects bullet-point on his resume. His movies are all buildup to an idea or concept that he never concludes or even cares about. He always falls back on special effects to dance around his lack of sophistication. Take Hellboy for instance, for some reason he spent what seemed like 30 minutes killing ONE tongue demon. As if he was compensating for the fact that he didn't know how to make an unaware agent of satan a compelling enough character. Instead Guillermo gave Hellboy as much charisma as a line spounting rubber doll, which was wierd since the comic character was facinating just to look at in comic form. I was surprised how little of that energy was transmitted to the movie version.
Fuck the Hobbits. Please stay away from that tired shit, Guillermo.
Move over Nick! Its devins turn at Chud.com to suck as much Del toro cock as possible! "Tastes like sweet taco's" Says Devin. I bet guillermo gives it to you extra hard if you mention the word "genius" repeatedly in every article related to him, right devin?
Hey, whether GdT does Hobbits 1 and 2 or more Cthulhu (yes, I count Hellboy – telling me that WASN'T a cthulhoid Great Old One at the climax?!?), to paraphrase that shitstorm AvP1: Whoever wins, we win. More GdT or more GdT? BRING IT!
"Alex P Keaton dilemma"? Jeez, maybe they could get those movies made in less than 5 years if they hired someone that DIDN'T have Parkinson's….
Yeah, I'm goin' to hell for that one….
I guess I'm shallow, because I thought Pan's Labyrinth was fantastic.
In this modern age of filmmaking, we don't have too many undisputed geniuses . Del Toro is one. If you don't agree…you just don't understand the medium. Drop.
BMLDTHOAG:
The fact that some people don't agree that del Toro is a genius MEANS that del Toro is NOT an 'undisputed' genius.
Buy a dictionary.
(For those who have found del Toro's work 'meaningless' or only full of cool imagery: You really need to check out The Devil's Backbone.)
There's absolutely no reason for The Hobbit to be 2 movies, besides CRAZY profits, I guess. There's less to that book than there is in one-eighth of LOTR. They should knock it down to a single satisfying movie, which would only take up Del Torro's time for less than two years.
I am with you on this one, it'll be rough to see GDT's prime eaten up by 2 epic movies, but you're right, it'll give him a nice chunk of change to play with, possibly allow him to open his own fx house or production company that'll allow not only his, but his protege's projects to shine through, and more risque' films to pop up in national releases. I'd like more films to get wide play and rock the boat away from the churn and burn crap we're seeing nowadays. It's a sacrifice, but I think he can do the Hobbit films justice, and then what could come after for him and his crew would be wonderous…
P,
The Hobbit would be 1 movie. The second movie is supposed to be some story that bridges the Hobbit to LOTR.
And GDT makes some entertaining pictures. Genius? Sure, why not. He does a better job than most writer/directors out there at telling a satisfying story that also looks good. He's not trying to change the way you think about society, he's just trying to entertain you. If you're looking for or need more than that you'll just be disappointed.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.