I’m not a big Chuck Klosterman fan. He’s an okay writer, but he’s devoid of insight or interest, and the people who find meaning or resonance in his work tend, in my opinion, to be pretty vapid. Some of his shorter work is tolerable on its own – I can deal with some of his essays, just not when they’re jammed into a full length book – but it’s unlikely I will ever forgive him for Killing Yourself to Live. And now it’s being made into a movie.
Killing Yourself to Live began life as a Spin magazine article (and a pretty good one, harkening back to the maxim that a little Klosterman goes a long way), where Klosterman traveled the country visiting famous rock death sites. It’s such a cool idea because rock is about two things – sex and death – and so many rock stars have such intriguing death stories.
The idea of blowing that article into a full fledged book seemed like a good one – you could get more rock minutia in there, and as a fan of travel writing*, I had hopes for some wryly observed thoughts on America. But instead Klosterman turned the book into a self-indulgent whine fest about his own relationships, each of which sounds to be about as mediocre as his writing. This is truly a guy who has lived his whole life at half wattage, and the idea that people are excited to consume his tepid stories baffles me.
Now the book is being turned into a movie. Klosterman tells Variety “The idea is to do a comedic road movie heavily based in rock ‘n’ roll,” but he doesn’t explain from where the narrative will come.
In the meantime, if you want to read a book by a rock journalist that successfully ties narcissistic musings to pop music and has a central story that carries some weight and profundity, check out Rob Sheffield’s ode to his late wife, Love Is A Mix Tape: Life and Loss, One Song At A Time.
* go read all of Paul Theroux’s travel books. Now. They’re amazing.





22 comments
My only experience with Klosterman is having select passages from "Sex, Drugs, and Cocoa Puffs" read to me at around 1AM by a very beautiful young woman moments before engaging in some very passionate sex. Having said that, I kind of like his work.
You're truly gifted, Devin, in your ability to make your opinion the standard-bearer when it comes to good taste. How nice to know. Fantastic insight as always. Thanks for sharing the news.
Your probably just dislike Klosterman because he writes about Kiss rather than critic bait like Gram Parsons.
Devin, you do realize their are other opinions in the world besides yours, and your continual mockery of people who like things you don't only beefs up your asshole image.
Wait a minute…
Well played sir, well played indeed.
That guy even looks like a hack. What's with his arms? They seem too long and big for him. And he looks a little like Sally Jesse Rapheal as well as Feldman. Wow, a lot of kids probably have no idea who Sally Jesse Rapheal is these days.
I don't care about Klosterman and I usually think it's funny how people on this site constantly rail against Devin for sharing his opinion when this is an opinion (and news) site. That said, I do have to admit that it seems of late that The Large-Breasted Bearded One has been increasing his tendency to not only put down things he doesn't like, but also the people who enjoy said things. It's knee-jerk defensive writing to preemptively attack people who you know will disagree with your opinion, and it makes you look like a weaker thinker/writer. (Just for clarity, "This is truly a guy who has lived his whole life at half wattage, and the idea that people are excited to consume his tepid stories baffles me" is unnecessarily condescending and adds nothing to your point).
I've only read Dark Star Safari by Paul Theroux but it was quite good. Ewan McGregor and Charley Boorman's travel books aren't quite as strong from a literary perspective but they're still a good read. I'm amazed Ewan's even returned to films – he seems to love motorbiking so much more.
"He's an okay writer, but he's devoid of insight or interest, and the people who find meaning or resonance in his work tend, in my opinion, to be pretty vapid."
"This is truly a guy who has lived his whole life at half wattage, and the idea that people are excited to consume his tepid stories baffles me."
Oh, like Stephanie Meyer and Twilight. I Getcha.
Oh c'mon. It's not wrong to demand a higher standard of writing from writers. Just because our generation is emotionally stunted to around the age of 11, doesn't mean we shouldn't demand intelligent, thoughtful writing. I haven't read Klosterman, but I'd never attack Devin for attacking vapidity.
Feldman looks like a dyke in that picture.
Shut up fatty
Rob Sheffield blows worse than Ridley Scott. Seriously, I have been reading Rollingstone for years and his articles are like listening to nails on a chalkboard. If it isn't gay, 80's new wave, ringtone rap or bubblegum pop, he doesn't like it. I can only stand so many articles about his obsession with Britney and every other talentless hack that is on TMZ every day. "Pop life" is the worst thing to happen to Rollingstone. Y'know it sucks that his wife died, but if I had to be around him all the time and listen to his lazy 80 mix-tape opinion, I would want to die too.
It really is amazing what a child Devin is. "If you like something I don't then you suck." The insecurity and infantile rage on display in every column he writes is breathtaking. "I don't like Sarah Palin so that means she tries to kill her baby" Pathetic.
I liked Sex, Drugs and Cocoa Puffs mostly, but the concept of that book didn't interest me and Corey Feldman doesn't interest me.
As guy who optioned KILLING YOURSELF TO LIVE to make into movie, just want to say I couldn't disagree with this guy more. If I'd of known Klosterman had a jealous, infantile counterpart, I'd of optioned that story as well. Guess we will see but i think this movie is going to be the seminal pop culture movie of the decade.
Tomorrow's NY Times headline: "Writer of Internet blog expresses opinion, world shits pants with rage"
I kind of like Klosterman, hes not Kurt Vonnegut by any means, but hes a fine writer for what he does. Devin, you sound like a dick the way you rail on people who dare to not think Klosterman is a hack the way you do. Its okay to have differing opinions ya know?
Growing up a few years and miles separated from the thematic setting and scope of "Fargo Rock City" I understand and lived a great deal of what he was trying to describe, only I found KISS intolerably lame. He's a certain kind of writer for a certain kind of fan, but in no way shapes the end of rock journalism or road trip nostalgia. I really don't see a point of making a movie about any of his books though.
There was definitely not enough Corey Feldman news in that article.
Damn Hipsters!
Seminal pop culture movie of the decade.
Shit, I couldn't be less interested in this movie. Think I'll just go watch Almost Famous again.
People who find meaning or resonance in Planet of the Apes and declare it the best of the Sci-Fi genre tend, in my opinion, to just be plain stupid.
Comments are shown as archived from the original site; new comments are closed.